Alan Lee – The Old Forest

In the Book:
At Crickhollow the Hobbits decide on a general plan of action for their coming travels. They sleep the night at Frodo’s new house, and rise early the next morning to begin the journey that will take them through the Old Forest. Though none of the hobbits are keen on going into it, the Forest presents the only route where they can get out of the Shire unnoticed. The dank, stifling, air, and the seeming watchfulness of the forest are disconcerting, to say the least, to the hobbits. Though the friends do their best to steer by the sun, the difficult terrain dictates their path and leads them not out of the forest but into its very heart. Heat and drowsiness- and perhaps something else- exhausts the hobbits, so that by early afternoon they are forced to rest for a time near a stream and an old Willow- this proves nearly fatal. The tree- the impression given is that this Old Man Willow is something of a dark Huorn – attempts to drown Frodo in the stream and traps Merry and Pippin beneath his roots. Sam, who was unharmed by the tree, hauls Frodo out of the water and the two then frantically try to free their young friends. In the nick of time, they encounter old Tom Bombadil.

In the movies: Omitted


John Howe – Old Man Willow

Why the change?
Like so many other post-Hobbiton pre-Bree scenes, this sequence was in all likelihood cut from the movie for time constraints; it slows the story down and delays the more complex and vital action.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Alternate Viewpoints/Questions [Submit Viewpoint/Question]
Old Man Willow Cameo by Eruantalincë

Related Information
Interesting Links
A summary of Lord Of the Rings: Fellowship of the Ring can be found in Elrond's Library.

Some articles that are related to this chapter:
Elrond's Library has all kinds of Hobbit-related poems and articles.

Forum threads related to this sequence:
- 1.VI. The Old Forest in the Book Club discusses this chapter in the book, with an emphasis on the 'character' of the Wood.

Take a look at how some artists interpreted this chapter:
- Into the Old Forest by Ted Nasmith
- The Old Forest by Eissmann
- The Old Forest by Lode Claes
- Old Man Willow by John Howe
- Old Man Willow by the brothers Hildebrandt
- Old Man Willow by Alan Lee
- Old Man Willow by Per Sjögren
- Old Man Willow by J.R.R. Tolkien

Not pleased with the book or the movie, take a look here: