(Note: Set in the early spring of the year 1409 SR, so Pippin is 19, Merry is 27, Frodo is 41 and Sam is 29. Bilbo would have left the Shire eight years earlier.)

I could hear Sam talking to someone as soon as I entered Bag End, shivering from the cold, freezing rain that was splattering down and coating all of Hobbiton with a thin layer of ice. In hindsight, I wondered what had possessed me to run out to the marketplace in such weather, and over Sam’s protestations, at that.

“Sam?” I called down the corridor, ready to admit my error.

He didn’t answer and I frowned as I hung my cloak up and deposited the packages onto the corridor table. I followed Sam’s voice to the study, glad to hear the crackle of a fire. I had opened my mouth to call to Sam again and ask who was here when I heard Pippin’s distinct voice respond to something Sam had just said.

Sure enough, when I entered the study, there was Pippin sitting on the floor in a miserable heap in front of the fireplace, surrounded by wet clothing that Sam was helping him divest of. “Why, Pippin!” I said, somewhat surprised to see my young cousin at Bag End, apparently alone, this late in the day. “What are you doing here?”

Pippin didn’t meet my eyes, concentrating instead on undoing the buttons on his coat, which appeared wet and dirty. “Can I stay here, Frodo?” he asked woefully.

“Of course,” I answered, trying to puzzle out what circumstances might have caused Pippin to show up alone on my doorstep in such weather. Sam was giving me that funny Sam look he gets when something unpleasant but not terrible has happened. I raised my eyebrows inquiringly at him as he took Pippin’s coat and piled it on top of the cloak and various other outerwear in his arms. Then he skirted the sofa and came over to me.

“I think he’s had some type of row down at the Smials, and then somehow slipped coming up the Hill from the stables and got himself right wet and cold,” Sam said low near my ear. “He showed up not long before you came in looking like a half-drowned cat and just as wretched.”

“Is that so?” I said, not matching Sam’s lowered voice. I moved around to stand in front of Pippin and surveyed him. He was still trembling from cold, despite the few minutes he had had beside the fire. His hair was wet, as were his trousers. His face was ruddy from the cold, and his nose was dripping. His bow-shaped mouth trembled with the effort to hold back tears, and he sniffled every minute or so.

“I’m just having a, a bad d-day,” Pippin said in great, gulping breaths that were almost, but not quite, sobs. He was still looking down, now working on his waistcoat buttons.

“Oh, Pip,” I said with tender exasperation. This little one had a knack for causing himself woe. Sam was about to bustle out of the room, and I turned to him. “Sam, would you be so kind as to draw Master Pippin a hot bath? I know he would appreciate it.”

“Certainly, Mr. Frodo,” Sam answered promptly. “Will you be wanting one as well?”

I waved his question off with a hand. “No, I’m fine, thank you, Sam. If you would just get his bath and then start fires in my room and Pippin’s usual one before you go.”

Sam nodded his head. “Yes, sir,” he replied and trooped out with Pippin’s pile of wet clothing.

“Thank you, Sam,” Pippin echoed me with the automatic good manners of a well-bred child, but Sam was already gone and Pippin’s voice was too thin to carry. I crouched down in front of him and gently touched a knee.

“Now, what’s all this?” I asked kindly. “Are you here alone? Where’s Merry or your father?”

He sniffled and wiped his nose on his shirt sleeve. “I lost my handkerchief,” he mumbled in misery.

“Oh, I can fix that fairly easily,” I answered, fishing through my pockets for the desired item. I located one in an inside coat pocket and handed it to my young cousin, who accepted it with a whispered, “Thank you,” and proceeded to blow his nose. He then sat silently, his jerky breath making his shoulders hitch. I picked up a cold foot and rubbed it between my hands briskly.

“Now tell me what is wrong,” I commanded as I continued to warm his foot.

He took a deep, shaky breath. “Nothing,” he said dejectedly. “I mean, nothing really. It’s silly and I’m just having a bad day and I slipped on the Hill and got simply soaking wet and it was already so cold and I haven’t had any tea and everyone is mad at me so I thought I would come here and maybe you would let me stay but then it was so very rainy and icy and windy and I just wanted to be somewhere warm and dry so please can I stay here, Frodo?”

The recitation increased in speed and pitch as it continued, ending with very-near tears and Pippin lifting his head to look at me with wet green eyes. I knew all of Pippin’s tricks, but this look wasn’t his playing-for-sympathies one, this was true wet-cold-hungry child misery. He could have asked me to run back out into the cold night and find fresh mushrooms for his supper and I would have said yes in the thrall of that face.

“Oh, Pip!” I said again, smiling with sympathy and placing a hand on his cold cheek. “Of course you can stay here. But what do you mean everyone is mad at you? And you did tell someone you were coming here, didn’t you?”

He sniffled and looked back down, mumbling something I couldn’t hear. I felt a pang of anxiety. If he had run off from the Smials without word and failed to turn up at bedtime, there would be an uproar that we would be able to hear right here in the study at Bag End. “Pippin?” I said sternly.

He twisted his hands around. “I told Toby I was coming here,” he said somewhat sullenly.

Well, those were not the best words he could have uttered, but they weren’t the worst either. Toby the elderly coachman couldn’t exactly give Pippin permission to come visiting in Hobbiton, but at least when his parents started hunting around for him, someone would be able to let them know where he was. I didn’t know if Pippin had ever gone anywhere without his father’s express permission before, and at 19, he really wasn’t allowed to traipse about the Shire alone, at least not so far and in this kind of weather.

I sighed. “All right, then,” I said, deciding to skip over the “everyone is mad at me” part for the moment. “Do you suppose Sam has that bath ready?”

Pip snuffled a little and shifted his legs as though they ached. “I hope so,” he said faintly, and then accepted my hand as I stood up. I pulled him to his feet, and he leaned in toward me, still holding my hand. “Thank you, Frodo,” he whispered.

I brushed wet, tangled curls from his forehead. “Of course, dearest,” I said quietly. Then I briskly announced, “Bath time for you, I think, then supper for us both and then bed. How will that do?”

Pippin didn’t answer, but nodded his head in agreement and headed out of the room. At the door, he let out a tremendous sneeze.

“Pippin!” I said, half laughing and half concerned. “Are you all right?”

He was, fortunately, still clutching my handkerchief, and he wiped his nose with it. “Yes,” he said, “just all cold and wet still.”

I gave him a little push into the corridor and down toward the bath room, now emitting promising-looking puffs of steam. “Well, then get in there and be all warm and wet, Master Peregrin. I’ll see to our supper.” Pippin steered himself into the bath room while I went to the kitchen, where I found the fire newly stoked and the tea kettle already on. The packages I had brought in had been directed to the proper places, and Sam was heaping firewood into the bin.

“All in order, Sam?” I asked, rummaging around for supper supplies.

“Yes, sir,” he answered. “There should be enough wood to last you and Master Pippin the night, and there’s a bit more in the bedrooms as well.”

“Then you should run home before the weather turns even worse,” I told him. “Mind yourself going down the Hill, and come back if it is too slick. You know that you can always stay here, and your folks will know where you are sure enough.”

“Thank you, Mr. Frodo.” Sam was already headed out the door. “You just let me know if you or Master Pippin need anything else, and I’ll be back first thing in the morning.”

“Thank you, Sam.” I put extra emphasis on my words and looked at Sam to show I meant them, and he blushed, then quickly shut the door on the bitter night.

I pulled together thick potato soup, bread, stewed beets and carrots, some cold slices of salted pork, and the last two pieces of a pumpkin pie. I added tea for us both, an ale for me and a glass of buttermilk for Pippin, and we were set. Pippin came into the kitchen, clean, dry and in fresh clothing, just as I set the last of the dishes on the table, demonstrating that no matter how poor of a day he was having, his ability to determine when the next meal was being served had not suffered.

“Mmm.” Pippin stood over the table and sniffed the pleasant aromas, looking much more content with his lot in life than he had when I first had come in. I pulled out his chair and then moved around the table to seat myself.

“Sit!” I ordered and he quickly complied. We filled the next half hour with clearing the table and there was very little talk, but finally even my cousin (and young hobbits do take a lot of feeding) seemed satisfied and pushed back his platter. I poured us both a fresh cup of tea and we sat for a while in familiar silence, a rare occurrence with Peregrin. I wondered if he was simply tired or if he was avoiding ‘fessing up to whatever crimes had led him to my door.

“So,” I finally said, “I am your last refuge, am I? Tell me what has led you to this sorry state of affairs.”

He fiddled with his tea spoon and did not meet my eyes. “I was mean to Pervinca,” he said after a long moment.

“How so?” I prodded. Pippin and his next-eldest sister had long been rivals for the attentions of both their parents and the children’s nurse, and squabbles between the two were not uncommon, though they had dropped off significantly as they had aged.

Pippin squirmed in his chair and I frowned. I had once seen the lad tackle his sister at the top of a knoll, toppling the two of them down the hill until they landed in the mud, ruining poor Pervinca’s new Litheday dress and pulling out a hunk of her hair in the process, and he had not looked so guilty at the end of that escapade as he did now.

The tips of his ears were furiously red, and he carefully studied the tabletop as he answered in a low voice, “I said she had a big mouth.”

I squelched a smile. Pervinca was a rather exuberant young lass who often could be heard over a throng of other tweenagers. “That’s all?” I asked, knowing full well it could not be.

Pippin’s whole face was red now. “No. I said that with her big mouth, she would have to find a lad who was a good as deaf if she wanted to get married.”

“Pippin!” I was truly astounded. Peregrin certainly has the Took capacity for getting himself into trouble, but never have I known him to be cruel or mean-spirited.

“I know,” he said wretchedly. “I am terribly sorry, and I tried to tell her so, but she wouldn’t even come out of her room to listen to me. And Father already scolded me horribly and said he was ashamed and that he should take a strap to me and I think Mamma cried because Pervinca cried so please don’t scold me more, I really am so very sorry.”

I swallowed back my words of reproach and drank some more of my tea instead of speaking my mind. When I spoke, my tone was serious, but I tried to keep any recrimination out of it.

“Do you know why you would say such a hurtful thing to your sister, Pippin? It is not like you to deliberately wound someone you love.”

He sniffled, and although he was the picture of misery, he was not crying. “But I don’t know, Frodo. My head hurt, and I had a horrid fight with Merry, and she was bothering me about every little thing that is going on in Buckland and asking me about this lad and that lad and did anyone ask after her while I was at the Hall. I said why would any lads be asking after her and I told her I wanted to be left alone and she said she could see why all the Brandybucks had sent me off, I was so unpleasant, and it just popped out before I knew I was going to say it.”

“Hmm.” I studied him hard and carefully reviewed the rambling confession in my head. “So that was when, last night? yesterday afternoon?”

He nodded and mumbled, “Afternoon.”

“And then your father reprimanded you and you hid all evening and then set for Hobbiton first thing this morning?”

He nodded again.

“And when did you have a horrid fight with Merry?”

“Oh!” Pippin looked surprised and I knew that he had not meant to let that bit of information slip before. “Um, at the Hall.”

“Yes, I know where,” I said as patiently as I could. Normally one could not get this lad to stop talking, but clearly I was going to have to drag the story out of him. “Did Merry’s folks send you home because of it? When did all this happen and what was it about? You and Merry hardly ever quarrel.”

Pippin chewed on his lower lip. “It wasn’t a quarrel,” he said in a low voice, “it was a fight. And Merry was mean and I think he meant it.”

We sat in silence for several minutes, and I had begun to think he wasn’t going to tell me at all when he finally began to speak.

“The Maggot lads were in with some deliveries to the Hall, and were waiting out the weather. We wanted to play roopie so we decided to play in that barn behind the west wing.” (Roopie being a popular game with the hobbit tweens and teens involving two balls, four sticks, and seven players. I had been quite the player at one time.) “But you know how things go, and, well, we ended up smashing a new pen wall and frightening a bunch of sheep half to death. Several of them got out, a couple even outside the barn, and we had a time getting them back in, and the ones that got outside were soaking wet and freezing.

“Anyway, Merry had to help us all clean up the mess, even though he hadn’t been playing, and then the farm hands had to fix the pen, and I think Uncle Saradoc was quite put out. But I don’t think he yelled at Merry, because it wasn’t his fault, and all he said to me was that I should start thinking about what could happen before doing things. But then Merry came and found me and was awfully mad.”

Pippin’s face was practically buried in his now-cold tea cup, but I still could see his lower lip trembling and I thought he was crying at this point. He took a quivering breath and continued.

“He said he was tired of having to clean up after me when I made a mess of things, and that those sheep could have been hurt or killed by a flying ball, and the ones that were so wet could get sick now. He said he was tired of me never thinking about the consequences of my actions, that I’m too old to be acting like a spoiled child. I told him I was sorry, but he just said I’m always sorry when something bad happens but I never care enough beforehand to act sensibly.”

Pippin was crying now, his breath coming in hitching gulps and his nose running freely. “So I told him it sounded like he didn’t even want me around and he said, he said that sometimes he, he thinks he doesn’t. So I said fine, I would just leave then and Merry just stomped off. So I left and came home to the Smials, but everything was just as bad there, and I don’t think Merry is my friend anymore, Frodo, and it’s just too awful to stand.” With this, Pippin burst into heartfelt sobs and put his head on the table.

I moved from across the table to the chair beside him and gently rubbed his back with one hand while I stroked his curls with the other. “Oh, Pippin, it’s all right,” I said. “Merry didn’t mean it, I know he didn’t. You must know how much he loves you.”

Pippin shook his head fiercely. “No, I’ve just misbehaved too many times for him to put up with me anymore. He hardly ever wants to play anymore, and he’s always talking about how this thing grows or that thing works at the Hall. He doesn’t have time for me and I’m always mucking up his plans. Nothing is like it used to be and I don’t think it’s ever going to go back.”

“Oh, Pip.” I didn’t know what to say to all this. Of course, Merry loved Pippin more than anything in Middle Earth, anyone who knew the two lads knew that, and these growing pains would not change that. But they had always had such an easy relationship, and Merry forgave any transgressions so readily, that I could see how this seemed the end of Pippin’s little world.

I let him cry for a while, and eventually his sobs quieted to heaving breaths. I discovered another handkerchief and pressed it into his hand, making a mental note that Pippin’s gift on my next birthday was going to be an entire box of handkerchiefs. He scrubbed at his face and blew his nose, then looked me in the face with mournful eyes. I pinched a cheek, a gesture he despised in elderly relations but sometimes tolerated from Merry or me.

“Bed?” I half-asked, half-ordered, and he nodded. I guided him down the corridor to his room, adjacent to mine, and saw him into a nightshirt and under the covers. Then I leaned over and brushed his hair off his hot face. “It will seem better tomorrow, Pippin,” I promised. “Just remember that Merry will always love you, no matter how angry he may be with you.” He looked doubtful, but he nodded dutifully. I sighed. “We’ll talk about it tomorrow, all right? Go to sleep.”

He was already curling into the little ball he sleeps in and burrowing under the blankets. I left the room quietly, leaving the door slightly ajar so I would hear if he woke distressed during the night. I cleared the supper table and went to bed.