Council of Elrond - Image Gallery
Title: Edoras
Submitted By: Elenisil
Date: October 11, 2002
You must be logged in to post a comment.
You must be logged in to post a comment.
35 Comments
primitive
very un-primitive, the entire things is made out of *stone* * Figwit coughs * stone…
one of the best illustrations of Tolkien i have seen
. . . nope
Interesting….
I like it alot, but i pictured Edoras more open, spred out and bigger. Not… like this.
I don’t like the stone
I think it should be made of wood.
well….i think this is his best…..
Doesn’t look Nordic enough. Tolkien said people of Rohan were Nordic.
no way.
How is that the Golden Hall? It’s a beige prison block!
not the way i imagined it. nice
I love the lighting and the mountains, but the GOLDEN hall needs some GOLD.
The Cathedral of Medulseld
The Cement Prison of Rohan
It’s just too big.
I pictured it more open-air and natural, but otherwise, it’s excellent.
Not very many windows…
it needs more windows… and I always pictured it sort of a golden-white sandstone color… and the thatched
roof doesn’t look thatched… it needs to be less blocky it does look like a prison…
Perhaps thats the real reason Eowyn wanted out..
It looks like a church from back before buttresses were invented.
WOOD. Meduseld is made of WOOD.
whats a buttress? hehehe
it’s NOT like a church…nor cathedral! it’s looks rather as one of the late Middle Ages castles or something.
…and it’s definitely not Meduseld!
not what I thought Meduseld looked like
i thought edoras was made out of wood???
No, i don’t think so….
ummm…. I like the horse in the center… not how I imagined Edoras, but still good!
Looks Egyptian…
Looks OK, but I like PJ’s better…more celtic, this looks more african or somethin’
It should look more like Heorot
Compare the size of the HORSE in the field to the size of the DOOR…