He’s pretty good looking for a man…
Aagh! The problem with the woman/man thing again! I’d say it’s a she.
It’s a man…if he were a woman he would have a chest…and I think we would all notice that. He sat to the
right of Elrond in the movie!
This person looks very Vulcan, but I can’t tell if it’s a man or a woman.
that’s a guy that’s Erestor Elrond’s cheif advisor he is girly lookin
Erestor. Mrr. He’s a guy and gorgeous, for those lovely comments above.
Stop nagging the poor boy, er… elf, He IS beautiful!
He kinda looks like he belongs in a cheap 70’s kung-fu movie.
WOW! Angilena Jo-Lee sure switched characters!
Oh, for the last time – this is a MALE Elf. MALE. ERESTOR. ELF. Get it? Good.
I know it’s a guy…just can’t get my brain to register that….nope…heck, it’s a shim!
I never had any amle/female problem with Elves. But this one is really on the edge! My vote goes for girl
HE looks plastic.
Mmm, shiny! *makes a point to rewatch the Council of Elrond scene specifically to see this Elf*
What is Romulan spy doing in Rivendel?
According to the canon, Erestor is an elf Lord of Rivendell….so either the casting dept. didn’t read closely
or said dept. did waaaay too good of a job on the whole elvish-androgyny thing here. Too much eyeshadow!
Can no one see the shadow above his upper lip? Of course it’s a guy!
This picture is kinda blurry… but in most pics, he looks like a guy. And he’s in the book, so we all KNOW.
Okay, I figured it out, It is a WOMAN actor playing a man!
ok lets solve this problem once and for all its a SHIM
lol. He’s not bad looking for a guy, but he’s kinda manish for a woman…
Dude . . it’s an Avari! A Dark Elf.
You mean they actually casted a REAL Avari Elf???!!! Wow… Anyway, they did their job wrong! But he’s still
kinda cute… Did I just write that?!
Hmmm….too much lipstick and eyeshadow. That’s what makes him look like a girl.
Oh, c’mon people! Ok, now I admit the makeup artist went a tad overboard here, but this is obviously a MAN.
and a darn FINE one at that. Sorta has a native-american/elf thing going on. Love those dark-haired elves!
Man. The guy who plays him is Jon Harding, or something like that, you can see at: http://www.geocities.com/pr
gah. http://www.geocities.com/protectorsoflorien/erestor1.html
ack! this is a scary picture… looks like he’s about to kill someone….
Wow, I guess the Vulcans have been around on Earth a lot longer than we thought… lol
Erestor is a male, and an Elf. And by the way, he rocks! He’s sarcastic,yes, but he rocks.
lol this convo is sooo funny to read
COME ON, people! Here’s the actor’s picture: http://www.theargonath.cc/cast/harding/harding.html
Nice pics of Jon there, Ereinion! I like the profile shot the best – he’s got great cheekbones! 😉
Thanks, but *whispers* They’re not mine… oh yeah, and crazy, I totally agree with you 😉
Erestor is half-noldo half-silvan, by the way. Avari means “Unwilling”. The Avari were those that turned back
to Cuvienen halfway to Valinor. That is definetely a guy. And he is gorgeous. I am an obsessive
Okay everyone: it’s a guy, it’s Erestor, and he’s not a vulcan.
He looks like a vampire and I didn´t have any problem with seeing him as a man. In fact I would never think hi
m as a woman. Too male face for that.
He does not look like an Elf at all.
hes hes either elladan or elrohir!!!!!!!!!! he was sitting right next to elrond in the movei!!!!
but if you pause it when Elrond tells Frodo to put the Ring on the table thingi he liiks hotter
Is currently debating on who look creepier, Erestor or Gil-gald (when he stabing the orc)
He is like 15 going on 1000 sigh… immortals… Cat’s gotta give up the coffee.
Looks like Kat from East enders!
Hey, what’s he doing in the misc. folder? Erestor is my favorite…
The person doesn’t look real…look like a digital picture of someone.
Wooooah, the first thing I thought was “Is that….Sirius Black?” Haha xD
I thought he was a girl at first glance…weird…
Wooooah….Young Elvish Snape much? Bahaha
You must be logged in to post a comment.
54 Comments
He’s pretty good looking for a man…
Aagh! The problem with the woman/man thing again! I’d say it’s a she.
It’s a man…if he were a woman he would have a chest…and I think we would all notice that. He sat to the
right of Elrond in the movie!
This person looks very Vulcan, but I can’t tell if it’s a man or a woman.
that’s a guy that’s Erestor Elrond’s cheif advisor he is girly lookin
Erestor. Mrr. He’s a guy and gorgeous, for those lovely comments above.
Stop nagging the poor boy, er… elf, He IS beautiful!
He kinda looks like he belongs in a cheap 70’s kung-fu movie.
WOW! Angilena Jo-Lee sure switched characters!
Oh, for the last time – this is a MALE Elf. MALE. ERESTOR. ELF. Get it? Good.
I know it’s a guy…just can’t get my brain to register that….nope…heck, it’s a shim!
I never had any amle/female problem with Elves. But this one is really on the edge! My vote goes for girl
HE looks plastic.
Mmm, shiny! *makes a point to rewatch the Council of Elrond scene specifically to see this Elf*
What is Romulan spy doing in Rivendel?
According to the canon, Erestor is an elf Lord of Rivendell….so either the casting dept. didn’t read closely
or said dept. did waaaay too good of a job on the whole elvish-androgyny thing here. Too much eyeshadow!
Can no one see the shadow above his upper lip? Of course it’s a guy!
This picture is kinda blurry… but in most pics, he looks like a guy. And he’s in the book, so we all KNOW.
Okay, I figured it out, It is a WOMAN actor playing a man!
ok lets solve this problem once and for all its a SHIM
lol. He’s not bad looking for a guy, but he’s kinda manish for a woman…
Dude . . it’s an Avari! A Dark Elf.
You mean they actually casted a REAL Avari Elf???!!! Wow… Anyway, they did their job wrong! But he’s still
kinda cute… Did I just write that?!
Hmmm….too much lipstick and eyeshadow. That’s what makes him look like a girl.
Oh, c’mon people! Ok, now I admit the makeup artist went a tad overboard here, but this is obviously a MAN.
and a darn FINE one at that. Sorta has a native-american/elf thing going on. Love those dark-haired elves!
Man. The guy who plays him is Jon Harding, or something like that, you can see at: http://www.geocities.com/pr
gah. http://www.geocities.com/protectorsoflorien/erestor1.html
ack! this is a scary picture… looks like he’s about to kill someone….
Wow, I guess the Vulcans have been around on Earth a lot longer than we thought… lol
Erestor is a male, and an Elf. And by the way, he rocks! He’s sarcastic,yes, but he rocks.
lol this convo is sooo funny to read
COME ON, people! Here’s the actor’s picture: http://www.theargonath.cc/cast/harding/harding.html
Nice pics of Jon there, Ereinion! I like the profile shot the best – he’s got great cheekbones! 😉
Thanks, but *whispers* They’re not mine… oh yeah, and crazy, I totally agree with you 😉
Erestor is half-noldo half-silvan, by the way. Avari means “Unwilling”. The Avari were those that turned back
to Cuvienen halfway to Valinor. That is definetely a guy. And he is gorgeous. I am an obsessive
Okay everyone: it’s a guy, it’s Erestor, and he’s not a vulcan.
He looks like a vampire and I didn´t have any problem with seeing him as a man. In fact I would never think hi
m as a woman. Too male face for that.
He does not look like an Elf at all.
hes hes either elladan or elrohir!!!!!!!!!! he was sitting right next to elrond in the movei!!!!
but if you pause it when Elrond tells Frodo to put the Ring on the table thingi he liiks hotter
Is currently debating on who look creepier, Erestor or Gil-gald (when he stabing the orc)
He is like 15 going on 1000 sigh… immortals… Cat’s gotta give up the coffee.
Looks like Kat from East enders!
Hey, what’s he doing in the misc. folder? Erestor is my favorite…
The person doesn’t look real…look like a digital picture of someone.
Wooooah, the first thing I thought was “Is that….Sirius Black?” Haha xD
I thought he was a girl at first glance…weird…
Wooooah….Young Elvish Snape much? Bahaha