Good question. It looks like he wants to kick serious Orc butt.
Poor Haldir… *kicks PJ*
Elves don’t really die, anyway. He’s reborn in Valinor, now !
*sighs and almost faints* no he should not have died, he would have been soo good in ROTK sniffles
hey elf luver…if you want the picture yourself, just buy the TTT 2004 day by day calendar. It’s in there.
I love the angry elf look!
Haldir should not have died,Haldir should not have died,Haldir should not have died*gasp*Haldir should not….
he looks shocked… like… “OMG! Legolas, you and Aragorn did WHAT to my shampoo?”
elves are just so cute when they’re angry…
Well, I’m not going to repeat that I wish he didn’t have to die soooo… I’ll just say I like the sword!
He was saposed to be in Lothloren (can’t spell) twitling his tumbs!!!! And thinking to him self if he should o
go to the grey havens
He is´n dad. (The Book)
BUT he wasnt even at Helm’s deep in the book. Why kill him off :*( …..WHY!!!
i wanna marry him!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! (drops died at the sound of the bang)
Is ther anyone how is´n in love with him?
Get them Haldir!
my brave haldir.
haldir my love
He shouldn’t have died. But, In a way he gets his due in RotK. When they toast to all those who fought and
Aragorn pauses to think. Well, that’s how I see it. Though it would have been better if he was ALIVE. Haldir!!
Haldir is doing a Legolas expression! Draw the knives and: Hiya! Kickin’ butt!
Sucks that he died.But in the books he didn’t appear again after Lothlorien. So, cutie, but not important.
Even though he’s unimportant he has a picture gallery dedicated to him*sniff* That way fangirls will still
…read his name.
Why on Middle-Earth did they make Haldir die?! Boromir was just enough…(don’t care about Denethor!)
there are no curses in elvish entish or the tongues of men that can (oh carp I forget how it goes, lol) anywat
Hey!! it didn’t let my finish my comment!! anyways, I’m gonna dedicate a part of my room to him, lol cool eh?
What part of the room? I’d hand a life size poster of him right above my bed if I could….*sigh*
Why the @%$#$$# did they kill him?!
HE WASN’T EVEN SUPPOSED TO DIE!!!!!!!!!!! He didn’t die in the book, cause he never even CAME to Helm’s Deep!!
WATCH OUT BEHIND YOU!
If the writers wanted to kill an Elf (and they DID want to), didn’t they notice all those OTHER Elves that
were laying on the wall in pieces??? Whad they have to take Haldir for???
that kinda thing can really ruin your day. and so can getting bitten to death by a pissed-off book fan
i like him hes cool
I didn’t want him to die!!! *Sob* WHY!?!?!? *Sob* I’m done now….
In all honesty, I don’t understand why everyone gets so upset about him dying. He doesn’t have that big a role
in the story.I was only concerned in that scene because I thought he was Legolas.
Neat bloody sword…
Well, maybe he died at the Battle of Mirkwood. Maybe it’s just as well.
I wish hadir never dies he is so sweet…but he kicked ass
He DIDN’T die.
I think it’ll be a shelf in my room, a nice corner one.. or maybe the whole corner, lol
He was cool at helms deep, but i always thought he was a fake looking elf
he will die now…damn
It makes me sad! He should not have died *sniff*
Oh my!
Shall I play taps for Haldir on my tin whistle? *plays taps* 2 min of silence.
Maybe we will remember him longer because he DID die…wish he didn’t tho
Jackson did it to show the elves’ vulnerability…couldn’t have happened to a
nicer Galadhrim
Though it was painful to watch him die–he fought hard. I love the expression on his face here, so surprised.
I think he should have had a bigger part, like being in the Fellowship!!!!
I have a compliment, I love the hair. What kind of shampoo did you use. I think I will get some.
very scarey, but still beautiful!
Haldir: What have I done?!
When he died, he didn’t get any blood on his beautiful face. That’s a good thing.
I mean I don’t wanna see him bloody… It’s nice that his death was….. I dunno.
WHY’DE HE HAVE TO DIE!*sobs*
HE”S NOT DEAD!!! HALDIR LIVES!!! in this case i’m going with the books…he didn’t even go to Helms Deep!
but he was much braver here in the movies…in the books he just sort of sat there in lothlorien
Poor Haldir…Well,atleast he looks awesome?
ok he didint die in the book now take a deep breath in out in out awwww
haldir is the coolest elf next to legolas
he didnt die really, because if an elf dies(he doesnt in the books anyways:P) they go to valinor, their home.
and i do love him its soo cute when aragorn hugs him and hes like all suprised lol i cried when he died then i
was like he DOESNT die in the books learn to research, its one thing putting him in a battle he shouldnt be in
but did he have to die?*breathes deep ish finished speach now*
HALDIR LIVES! I really don’t care what PJ says!!
lady alias i agree w/u the look on haldirs face when aragorn hugs him is ADORABLE. i cried when he died 2
bad hair day!
but hey he looks good
*cries * *sobs* i cried when aragorn hugs haldir *sobs*
*sobs*sob*why*sobs*does*sobs*he*cry*have*sobcry*to*cry*die!?!?!?(why does he have to die?!)
*TEARS* I know i wish he didn’t have to die!!!! I cried sooooo much during that scene *more tears*
i cried when haldir died i was so sad!
I have this picture…*Still doesn’t get why everyone is crying*
i’m right there with u. i love Haldir…*scolds Tolkien*
if it makes any difference, Haldir did die in the book. However, it was on the…borders, I think, of Lorien
he’s fighting a load of fangirls to get into macdonalds
he looks rather funny yes, i think this is when Aragon called up to him “Haldir to the keep”
He looks as if someone just made him a permanent soprano :P. And to all you crying fangirls, Haldir did NOT
die in the book.
die villain
i love haldir. he shouldn’t have died.
Of course he died in the movie! It’s because I liked him! The ones I like always die!
It could have been any other elf….but Haldir…! Nooooooooo!!!!!
Haldir is Awesome! I know he didn’t die in the book, but at least he died a semi-honorable death
okay very honorable death, in the movie.
Yeh but when Aragorn put his hands on his chest to say goodbye, he could of at least cleaned them!
Even when he’s angry, he is beautiful!!!
I LOVE YOU HALDIR!!!!!! *sniffles* He died in movie!!! But he not die in book!! woohoo!!!
why did they put him in the battle though? he didn’t die in book and wasn’t in the battle there either,
Learn to read things before you put them in you stuipid movie writer people!!!! *goes on rant*
The most awful thing in his death in the movie was not the death itself. It was the realization, that he
brought all these elves to the Helm’s Deep just to die…
yeah…i agree with lirulin, just the fact that he looks so shocked at death, i mean, he’s an elf, so he’s
wondering what the heck is going on…i mean, he never expected to die…he’s an elf after all. kinda cute too
Yah Why’d he have to die? ;_;
*sniffle* WHY?!? *starts hysterical crying* WAAAAAAHHHHH!!!!!!!!
You must be logged in to post a comment.
101 Comments
Good question. It looks like he wants to kick serious Orc butt.
Poor Haldir… *kicks PJ*
Elves don’t really die, anyway. He’s reborn in Valinor, now !
*sighs and almost faints* no he should not have died, he would have been soo good in ROTK sniffles
hey elf luver…if you want the picture yourself, just buy the TTT 2004 day by day calendar. It’s in there.
I love the angry elf look!
Haldir should not have died,Haldir should not have died,Haldir should not have died*gasp*Haldir should not….
he looks shocked… like… “OMG! Legolas, you and Aragorn did WHAT to my shampoo?”
elves are just so cute when they’re angry…
Well, I’m not going to repeat that I wish he didn’t have to die soooo… I’ll just say I like the sword!
He was saposed to be in Lothloren (can’t spell) twitling his tumbs!!!! And thinking to him self if he should o
go to the grey havens
He is´n dad. (The Book)
BUT he wasnt even at Helm’s deep in the book. Why kill him off :*( …..WHY!!!
i wanna marry him!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! (drops died at the sound of the bang)
Is ther anyone how is´n in love with him?
Get them Haldir!
my brave haldir.
haldir my love
He shouldn’t have died. But, In a way he gets his due in RotK. When they toast to all those who fought and
Aragorn pauses to think. Well, that’s how I see it. Though it would have been better if he was ALIVE. Haldir!!
Haldir is doing a Legolas expression! Draw the knives and: Hiya! Kickin’ butt!
Sucks that he died.But in the books he didn’t appear again after Lothlorien. So, cutie, but not important.
Even though he’s unimportant he has a picture gallery dedicated to him*sniff* That way fangirls will still
…read his name.
Why on Middle-Earth did they make Haldir die?! Boromir was just enough…(don’t care about Denethor!)
there are no curses in elvish entish or the tongues of men that can (oh carp I forget how it goes, lol) anywat
Hey!! it didn’t let my finish my comment!! anyways, I’m gonna dedicate a part of my room to him, lol cool eh?
What part of the room? I’d hand a life size poster of him right above my bed if I could….*sigh*
Why the @%$#$$# did they kill him?!
HE WASN’T EVEN SUPPOSED TO DIE!!!!!!!!!!! He didn’t die in the book, cause he never even CAME to Helm’s Deep!!
WATCH OUT BEHIND YOU!
If the writers wanted to kill an Elf (and they DID want to), didn’t they notice all those OTHER Elves that
were laying on the wall in pieces??? Whad they have to take Haldir for???
that kinda thing can really ruin your day. and so can getting bitten to death by a pissed-off book fan
i like him hes cool
I didn’t want him to die!!! *Sob* WHY!?!?!? *Sob* I’m done now….
In all honesty, I don’t understand why everyone gets so upset about him dying. He doesn’t have that big a role
in the story.I was only concerned in that scene because I thought he was Legolas.
Neat bloody sword…
Well, maybe he died at the Battle of Mirkwood. Maybe it’s just as well.
I wish hadir never dies he is so sweet…but he kicked ass
He DIDN’T die.
I think it’ll be a shelf in my room, a nice corner one.. or maybe the whole corner, lol
He was cool at helms deep, but i always thought he was a fake looking elf
he will die now…damn
It makes me sad! He should not have died *sniff*
Oh my!
Shall I play taps for Haldir on my tin whistle? *plays taps* 2 min of silence.
Maybe we will remember him longer because he DID die…wish he didn’t tho
Jackson did it to show the elves’ vulnerability…couldn’t have happened to a
nicer Galadhrim
Though it was painful to watch him die–he fought hard. I love the expression on his face here, so surprised.
I think he should have had a bigger part, like being in the Fellowship!!!!
I have a compliment, I love the hair. What kind of shampoo did you use. I think I will get some.
very scarey, but still beautiful!
Haldir: What have I done?!
When he died, he didn’t get any blood on his beautiful face. That’s a good thing.
I mean I don’t wanna see him bloody… It’s nice that his death was….. I dunno.
WHY’DE HE HAVE TO DIE!*sobs*
HE”S NOT DEAD!!! HALDIR LIVES!!! in this case i’m going with the books…he didn’t even go to Helms Deep!
but he was much braver here in the movies…in the books he just sort of sat there in lothlorien
Poor Haldir…Well,atleast he looks awesome?
ok he didint die in the book now take a deep breath in out in out awwww
haldir is the coolest elf next to legolas
he didnt die really, because if an elf dies(he doesnt in the books anyways:P) they go to valinor, their home.
and i do love him its soo cute when aragorn hugs him and hes like all suprised lol i cried when he died then i
was like he DOESNT die in the books learn to research, its one thing putting him in a battle he shouldnt be in
but did he have to die?*breathes deep ish finished speach now*
HALDIR LIVES! I really don’t care what PJ says!!
lady alias i agree w/u the look on haldirs face when aragorn hugs him is ADORABLE. i cried when he died 2
bad hair day!
but hey he looks good
*cries * *sobs* i cried when aragorn hugs haldir *sobs*
*sobs*sob*why*sobs*does*sobs*he*cry*have*sobcry*to*cry*die!?!?!?(why does he have to die?!)
*TEARS* I know i wish he didn’t have to die!!!! I cried sooooo much during that scene *more tears*
i cried when haldir died i was so sad!
I have this picture…*Still doesn’t get why everyone is crying*
i’m right there with u. i love Haldir…*scolds Tolkien*
if it makes any difference, Haldir did die in the book. However, it was on the…borders, I think, of Lorien
he’s fighting a load of fangirls to get into macdonalds
he looks rather funny yes, i think this is when Aragon called up to him “Haldir to the keep”
He looks as if someone just made him a permanent soprano :P. And to all you crying fangirls, Haldir did NOT
die in the book.
die villain
i love haldir. he shouldn’t have died.
Of course he died in the movie! It’s because I liked him! The ones I like always die!
It could have been any other elf….but Haldir…! Nooooooooo!!!!!
Haldir is Awesome! I know he didn’t die in the book, but at least he died a semi-honorable death
okay very honorable death, in the movie.
Yeh but when Aragorn put his hands on his chest to say goodbye, he could of at least cleaned them!
Even when he’s angry, he is beautiful!!!
I LOVE YOU HALDIR!!!!!! *sniffles* He died in movie!!! But he not die in book!! woohoo!!!
why did they put him in the battle though? he didn’t die in book and wasn’t in the battle there either,
Learn to read things before you put them in you stuipid movie writer people!!!! *goes on rant*
The most awful thing in his death in the movie was not the death itself. It was the realization, that he
brought all these elves to the Helm’s Deep just to die…
yeah…i agree with lirulin, just the fact that he looks so shocked at death, i mean, he’s an elf, so he’s
wondering what the heck is going on…i mean, he never expected to die…he’s an elf after all. kinda cute too
Yah Why’d he have to die? ;_;
*sniffle* WHY?!? *starts hysterical crying* WAAAAAAHHHHH!!!!!!!!