AGH! What is this business? ‘I am happy for you.’ Does no one understand Aragorn IS TAKEN?!!*Sorry all…sigh*
Of course not: Aragorn and Arwen broke up in the movie, and even if they hadn’t how could they have known?
well she could have come to him in a dream.
I want her hair!
Yeah, I think it HIGHLY likely that Theoden totally missed that Aragorn was ever in love with someone else.
I think in Medievil (sp?) times that if you drank from the cup offered to you by a maiden
it meant you were serious about her. Her offering the cup certainly meant she was serious about you
I think Aragorn having been too long in the wilds, forgot about this custom
I love her hair! Why can’t everyone be blessed with hair like her’s?
No, the cup is simply a parting gesture, but it’s used incorrectly here.
It was something like the cup of Parting, I read it in the book (although why it’s parting when he just
arrived I just can’t fathom….)
The stirrup cup is in the books, where she brings him the cup just before he heads off. But in this context I
think Aravilui is right.
You must be logged in to post a comment.
14 Comments
AGH! What is this business? ‘I am happy for you.’ Does no one understand Aragorn IS TAKEN?!!*Sorry all…sigh*
Of course not: Aragorn and Arwen broke up in the movie, and even if they hadn’t how could they have known?
well she could have come to him in a dream.
I want her hair!
Yeah, I think it HIGHLY likely that Theoden totally missed that Aragorn was ever in love with someone else.
I think in Medievil (sp?) times that if you drank from the cup offered to you by a maiden
it meant you were serious about her. Her offering the cup certainly meant she was serious about you
I think Aragorn having been too long in the wilds, forgot about this custom
I love her hair! Why can’t everyone be blessed with hair like her’s?
No, the cup is simply a parting gesture, but it’s used incorrectly here.
It was something like the cup of Parting, I read it in the book (although why it’s parting when he just
arrived I just can’t fathom….)
The stirrup cup is in the books, where she brings him the cup just before he heads off. But in this context I
think Aravilui is right.